Catholic Saints · York
- Venerable
- d. c. 1556–1586
- 1 source

Venerable Margaret Clitherow (c. 1556–1586)
Why did Venerable Margaret Clitherow refuse to enter a plea at her York trial in March 1586?
Venerable Margaret Clitherow, called the 'Pearl of York', married John Clitherow on 8 July 1571 and converted to Catholicism about three years later, harbouring missionary priests at her home in the Shambles. Arrested in March 1586, she refused to plead at trial to spare her children and servants and was pressed to death on 25 March 1586.12
Life and remembrance
Margaret Clitherow, called the 'Pearl of York', was born about 1556, the daughter of Thomas Middleton, a wax-chandler and Sheriff of York in 1564–1565, and died at York on 25 March 1586. On 8 July 1571 she married John Clitherow, a wealthy butcher and chamberlain of the city, in Saint Martin's church, Coney Street, and lived in the Shambles.1
Converted to the Catholic Faith about three years after her marriage, she continually risked her life by harbouring and maintaining missionary priests and endured frequent imprisonments—sometimes for two years at a time—without ever losing courage. Although her husband belonged to the Established Church, his brother was a Catholic priest, and Margaret provided two hidden chambers, one adjoining her house in the Shambles and a second in another part of York, where she kept priests concealed and had Mass celebrated continually through the height of the persecution. When several of the priests she sheltered were martyred, she made secret pilgrimages by night to York Tyburn to pray beneath the gibbet that she might receive the same grace.2
Arrested on 10 March 1586 and committed to York Castle, she was arraigned on 14 March at the York assizes before Judges Clinch and Rhodes and several members of the Council of the North on charges of harbouring priests and hearing Mass. Because the only witnesses against her would be her own little children and servants, whom she could not bear to involve in the guilt of her death, she refused to plead and was condemned to the peine forte et dure—to be pressed to death—replying, 'God be thanked, I am not worthy of so good a death as this.'1
Although she was probably with child, the sentence was carried out on Lady Day, 25 March 1586 (Good Friday according to the New Style). After overcoming an agony of fear the night before, she walked barefoot, calm, and smiling to the tolbooth on Ousebridge, having sent her hose and shoes to her daughter Anne in token that she should follow in her steps. Answering the sheriff and ministers that she died for the love of her Lord Jesus, she was laid upon the ground with a sharp stone beneath her back and her hands stretched out in the form of a cross and bound to two posts, while a weighted door crushed her to death during a fifteen-minute agony as she cried, 'Jesu! Jesu! Jesu! have mercy on me!' Her right hand is preserved at Saint Mary's Convent in York, though the resting-place of her body is unknown; her sons Henry and William became priests, and her daughter Anne became a nun at Saint Ursula's in Louvain.2
Other accounts and ways this saint is remembered
The contemporary biography of Margaret Clitherow written by her confessor, Father John Mush, survives in two versions: the earlier version was edited by Father John Morris, S.J., in The Troubles of Our Catholic Forefathers (Third Series, London, 1877), and the later manuscript at York Convent was published by W. Nicholson of Thelwall Hall, Cheshire (London and Derby, 1849).2
Remember
- Born about 1556 to Sheriff Thomas Middleton of York; married John Clitherow on 8 July 1571 in Saint Martin's church, Coney Street, and converted about three years later.1
- Maintained two hidden chambers in York for missionary priests and made secret night pilgrimages to pray beneath the gibbet at York Tyburn.2
- Arraigned on 14 March 1586 before Judges Clinch and Rhodes, she refused to plead so that her own children and servants would not be forced to testify against her.1
- Pressed to death under a weighted door at the tolbooth on Ousebridge on Lady Day (Good Friday), 25 March 1586; her right hand is preserved at Saint Mary's Convent, York.2
Check yourself
Which confessor of the York martyr wrote her contemporary biography preserved in two manuscript versions?
Facts and sources
Each fact names its source. The label shows how sure we can be.
The Church status of Venerable Margaret Clitherow is Venerable.
Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume IV: Cland–Diocesanvol. IV, pp. 59–59 (clean-text lines 11127–11202)
Born about 1556 to Sheriff Thomas Middleton of York, Margaret married John Clitherow in Saint Martin's church, Coney Street, on 8 July 1571 and converted to Catholicism about three years later.
Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume IV: Cland–Diocesanvol. IV, pp. 59–59 (clean-text lines 11127–11135)
Refusing to plead at her trial on 14 March 1586 to spare her children and servants from testifying against her, she was pressed to death at the tolbooth on Ousebridge on Lady Day (Good Friday), 25 March 1586.
Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume IV: Cland–Diocesanvol. IV, pp. 59–59 (clean-text lines 11148–11178)
Sources
Bede Camm, “Clitherow, Venerable,” The Catholic Encyclopedia (1908), vol. IV, p. 59. About this source
Notes and sources
About the source edition · Bede Camm, The Catholic Encyclopedia (1909), vol. IV, pp. 59–59
1. Establishes her birth about 1556 as daughter of Sheriff Thomas Middleton, marriage to John Clitherow on 8 July 1571, conversion three years later, and maintenance of two secret chambers for priests.
1. Birth c. 1556, marriage to John Clitherow on 8 July 1571, conversion, and harbouring of priests in the ShamblesLines 11127–11148
Original passage
“married John Clitherow, a wealthy butcher and a chamberlain of the city, in St. Martin's church, Coney St., 8 July, 1571, and lived in the Shambles, a street still unaltered.”
2. Documents her arrest on 10 March 1586, refusal to plead on 14 March to spare her children and servants, execution by peine forte et dure at the Ousebridge tolbooth on Lady Day (25 March 1586), relic at Saint Mary's Convent in York, and religious vocations of her children Henry, William, and Anne.
2. Arrest (10 March 1586), arraignment before Judges Clinch and Rhodes (14 March), refusal to plead, and martyrdom on Ousebridge (25 March 1586)Lines 11148–11183
Original passage
“Finally arrested on 10 March, 1586, she was committed to the castle. On 14 March, she was arraigned before Judges Clinch and Rhodes and several members of the Council of the North at the Y'ork assizes.”
Found an error? Report a correction.
