Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Catholic Saints · Rome

  • Canonized Saint
  • Feast 17 April
  • d. April (16, 17, or 20 April, c. 161 or c. 168), Rome
  • 3 sources
Mosaic portrait of Pope Saint Anicetus

Pope Saint Anicetus (d. c. 161)

Also known as Saint Anicetus, Pope Anicetus

How did Pope Saint Anicetus and Saint Polycarp of Smyrna handle the Paschal controversy at Rome?

Pope Saint Anicetus succeeded Pope Pius I around 157 and governed the Roman Church until about 168. During his pontificate he conferred in Rome with Saint Polycarp of Smyrna over the Paschal date while preserving full charity, welcomed the Christian historian Hegesippus, and opposed Gnostic teachers in Rome.12

Life and remembrance

Traditional account

Pope Saint Anicetus succeeded Pope Pius I toward the year 157 and reigned until about 168, though as Louis Duchesne notes in his Origines, the chronological confusion in the surviving second-century lists prevents more exact verification of these dates. Between 160 and 162, during Anicetus's pontificate, the aged Saint Polycarp of Smyrna travelled to Rome to confer with him regarding the Paschal controversy. Polycarp and the churches of Asia Minor celebrated the Paschal feast on the fourteenth day of the Jewish month of Nisan regardless of the day of the week on which it fell, whereas in Rome Easter was always kept on Sunday and the commemoration of the Lord's Passion on Friday. Although the question was discussed without reaching a uniform rule—since, in the words preserved by Eusebius, 'Polycarp could not persuade the Pope, nor the Pope, Polycarp'—the bonds of charity remained unbroken, and Anicetus permitted the venerable Bishop of Smyrna to celebrate according to the custom of his church.1

Around the same time Hegesippus, the earliest Christian church historian, whose writings held particular value because of his proximity to the Apostolic age, also visited Rome—a journey cited by ecclesiastical writers as evidence of how prominent Christians from across the Empire repaired to the Roman See and recognized the authority of the Roman Pontiffs. During Anicetus's reign the heretics Marcion, Marcellinus, Valentinus, and Cerdo were likewise present in Rome, troubling the Church with their dualistic and Gnostic doctrines. Traditional notices state that Anicetus suffered martyrdom in 161, with his liturgical commemoration varying between 16, 17, and 20 April.2

Earlier liturgical and hagiographical chronology placed Anicetus's pontificate of roughly eight years from 165 to 173 following Pope Saint Pius I in the reign of Antoninus Pius, noting that even if he did not shed his blood by the sword, he merited the title of martyr in the Roman Martyrology through the severe sufferings and perils of his episcopate. With pastoral vigilance he guarded the Roman flock against the Gnostic teachers Valentinus and Marcion: Marcion, excommunicated in Pontus by his own father the bishop, sought communion at Rome but was refused until he should make satisfaction by penance to his lawful prelate, whereupon he joined the Syrian dualist Cerdo in positing two rival first principles.34

Remember

  • Pope Saint Anicetus succeeded Pope Pius I around 157 and reigned until about 168, though exact second-century papal dates remain uncertain.1
  • Between 160 and 162 Saint Polycarp of Smyrna visited Rome to discuss the Paschal controversy with Anicetus, comparing the Eastern 14 Nisan observance with the Roman Sunday Easter.1
  • Neither prelate persuaded the other to abandon his custom, yet they remained in full communion and charity, and Anicetus allowed Polycarp to celebrate according to the Smyrnaean rite.1
  • During his pontificate the early Christian historian Hegesippus visited Rome, while Marcion, Marcellinus, Valentinus, and Cerdo propagated their heretical teachings in the city.2
  • Tradition records that Anicetus died a martyr, with his feast day assigned variously to 16, 17, or 20 April.2

Check yourself

What was the outcome of the conference in Rome between Pope Saint Anicetus and Saint Polycarp of Smyrna over the date of Easter, and which early Christian historian also visited Rome during Anicetus's pontificate?

Writings and words

“Polycarp could not persuade the Pope, nor the Pope, Polycarp. The controversy was not ended but the bonds of charity were not broken”

vol. I, p. 514 (clean-text lines 86162–86165; Eusebius)

Feast days and patronage

  • 17 April — General Roman Calendar (1907) (Universal (variants 16 and 20 April) · memorial)

Facts and sources

Each fact names its source. The label shows how sure we can be.

  1. The Church status of Pope Saint Anicetus is Saint.

    Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume I: Aachen–Assizevol. I, p. 514 (clean-text lines 86149)

  2. Pope Saint Anicetus succeeded Pope Pius I toward 157 and reigned until about 168, though exact dates for this period cannot be verified with certainty.

    Attributed: A source reports this, but we are not sure it is true or who said itThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume I: Aachen–Assizevol. I, p. 514 (clean-text lines 86149–86153)

  3. Between 160 and 162 Saint Polycarp of Smyrna conferred in Rome with Anicetus over the Paschal controversy (14 Nisan versus Sunday Easter); neither persuaded the other, yet the bonds of charity remained unbroken.

    Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume I: Aachen–Assizevol. I, p. 514 (clean-text lines 86153–86168)

  4. During Anicetus's pontificate the early Christian historian Hegesippus visited Rome, while Marcion, Marcellinus, Valentinus, and Cerdo disturbed the Roman Church with their heretical teachings.

    Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume I: Aachen–Assizevol. I, p. 514 (clean-text lines 86170–86180)

  5. Tradition states that Anicetus suffered martyrdom (dated in some notices to 161), with his liturgical commemoration varying between 16, 17, and 20 April.

    Tradition: A story passed down through faith or recorded laterThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume I: Aachen–Assizevol. I, p. 514 (clean-text lines 86180–86182)

  6. Sources cited for Pope Saint Anicetus are Acta Sanctorum (April), Butler (Lives of the Saints, 17 April), Michaud (Biographie Universelle), Jungmann (Dissert. Hist. Eccl.), and Moberly in Dictionary of Christian Biography.

    Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume I: Aachen–Assizevol. I, p. 514 (clean-text lines 86184–86186)

  7. Even if Pope Anicetus did not die by execution, he merited the title of martyr in the Roman Martyrology through the sufferings and dangers of his pontificate while protecting the Roman Church against Valentine and Marcion and tolerating the Asiatic Paschal custom observed by Saint Polycarp.

    Verified: Directly supported by strong evidencePictorial Lives of the Saints, with Reflections for Every Day in the YearJohn Gilmary Shea (ed.), Pictorial Lives of the Saints (1889), April 17, St. Anicetus, Pope, Martyr, lines 8627-8635

  8. Excommunicated in Pontus by his own father the bishop, Marcion travelled to Rome seeking communion but was rejected until he made penitential satisfaction to his bishop, after which he joined the Syrian heresiarch Cerdo in teaching two rival first principles.

    Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Lives of the Fathers, Martyrs, and Other Principal SaintsAlban Butler, Lives of the Fathers, Martyrs, and Other Principal Saints (1866), April 17, St. Anicetus, Pope and Martyr, lines 8474-8503

Sources

T. J. Campbell, “Anicetus, Saint,” The Catholic Encyclopedia (1907), vol. I, p. 514. About this source

Notes and sources

  1. 1. Covers his reign from c. 157 to c. 168 after Pius I, Louis Duchesne's note on chronological uncertainty, and the Paschal conference with Saint Polycarp of Smyrna (160–162) recorded by Eusebius.

    1. Succession after Pius I (c. 157–168), Duchesne on chronology, and conference with Saint Polycarp on the Paschal date (160–162)Lines 86149–86168

    Original passage

    “Anicetus, Saint, Pope, the Roman Pontiff who succeeded Pius towards the year 157, and reigned till about 168. According to Duchesne (Origines) the confusion of dates about this period is such that more exact verification is impo.ssible. While Anicetus was Pope, St. Polycarp, then in extreme old age, came to confer with him (160-162) about the Paschal controversy; Polycarp and others in the East celebrating the feast on the fourteenth of the month of Nisan, no matter on what day of the week it fell; whereas in Rome it was always observed on Stmday, and the day of the Lord's death on Friday. The matter w!us clisciL'wed but nothing was decided. According to l-.ascl)iiLs: "Polycarp could not per.suade the Pope, nor the Pope, Polycarp. The controversy was not ended but the bonds of charity were not broken"; the Pope permitting the aged saint to celebrate on the day he had been accustomed to in the Church of Smyrna.”
  2. 2. Covers the visit of Hegesippus to Rome, the activity of Marcion, Marcellinus, Valentinus, and Cerdo, the traditional martyrdom year of 161 (alongside the c. 168 reign end given in line 86151), and the feast dates of 16, 17, and 20 April. Bibliography cited for Pass 2 retrieval: Acta Sanctorum, 17 April (printed 11 April in OCR); Alban Butler, Lives of the Saints, 17 April; Michaud, Biographie Universelle; Bernard Jungmann, Dissertationes Selectae in Historiam Ecclesiasticam; George H. Moberly in Dictionary of Christian Biography.

    2. Visit of Hegesippus to Rome, Marcion, Marcellinus, Valentinus, and Cerdo, martyrdom notice, and April feast datesLines 86170–86189

    Original passage

    “Hegesippus, the first Christian historian whose writings are of great value, because he lived so near the time of the Apostles, also came to Rome at this time. His visit is recorded by most ecclesiastical authors as noteworthy, inasmuch as it calls attention to the fact that many illustrious men repaired to Rome at that period, thus emphasizing very early the supreme dignity and authority of the Roman Pontiffs. Marcion, Marcellinus, Valentine, and Cerdo were also at Rome, disturbing the Church by their Manichaeism. Anicetus suffered martyrdom in 161, but the dates vary between 16, 17, and 20 April. Acta SS„ 11 April; Butler, Lives of the Saints, 17 April; MicHAUD, Biog. Univ.; Jungmann, Dissert. Hist. EccL; Mo- BERLT in Diet. Christ. Biogr. T. J. C.VMPBELL.”
  3. 3. Notes the traditional 165–173 dating of Anicetus's eight-year pontificate after Saint Pius I, his title of martyr through sufferings and dangers, his reception of Saint Polycarp, and his vigilance against Valentine and Marcion.

    3. Traditional dating (165-173), title of martyr earned through sufferings, tolerance of the Asiatic Paschal custom for St. Polycarp, and defence against Valentine and MarcionLines 8627–8635

    About this source edition

    John Gilmary Shea (ed.), Pictorial Lives of the Saints (1889), April 17, St. Anicetus, Pope, Martyr, lines 8627-8635

    Original passage

    “If he did not shed his blood for the faith, he at least purchased the title of martyr by great suf- ferings and dangers. He received a visit from St. Polycarp, and tolerated the custom of the Asiatics in celebrating Easter on the 14th day of the first moon after the vernal equinox, with the Jews.”
  4. 4. Details the Roman Church's refusal to admit Marcion to communion without penance to his father and bishop in Pontus, and Marcion's subsequent dualist heresy alongside Cerdo of Syria.

    4. Rejection of the excommunicated Marcion at Rome until he made penitential satisfaction to his bishop in Pontus, and Marcion's alliance with CerdoLines 8474–8503

    About this source edition

    Alban Butler, Lives of the Fathers, Martyrs, and Other Principal Saints (1866), April 17, St. Anicetus, Pope and Martyr, lines 8474-8503

    Original passage

    “He came to Rome in hopes to be there received into the communion of the church, but was rejected till he had made satisfaction, by penance, to his own bishop. Upon which he commenced heresiarch, as Tertullian and St. Epiphanius relate. He professed himself a stoic philosopher, and seems to have been a priest.”

Found an error? Report a correction.