Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Catholic Saints · Alexandria

  • Canonized Saint
  • Feast 3 July
  • d. 458 at Constantinople (feast 3 July)
  • 1 source
Mosaic portrait of Saint Anatolius of Constantinople

Saint Anatolius of Constantinople (d. 458)

Also known as Anatolius the Patriarch

How did Saint Anatolius of Constantinople oppose Dioscurus at the Council of Chalcedon?

Saint Anatolius of Constantinople (born at Alexandria, died 458, feast 3 July) was Patriarch of Constantinople for eight years from 449. Though elevated through the influence of Dioscurus of Alexandria, he condemned Dioscurus and Eutyches at the Council of Chalcedon in 451.12

Life and remembrance

Traditional account

Saint Anatolius, born at Alexandria, distinguished himself at Ephesus against Nestorius and at Constantinople against Eutyches before becoming Patriarch of Constantinople during the reign of Emperor Theodosius II. The Monophysite Patriarch Dioscurus of Alexandria promoted his elevation to the see of Constantinople in hopes of securing an ally, but Anatolius proved a resolute opponent of Monophysitism and condemned Dioscurus and his followers at the Council of Chalcedon in 451.12

Cardinal Caesar Baronius sharply criticized Anatolius for accepting consecration from Dioscurus, for seeking patriarchal precedence for Constantinople over Antioch and Alexandria against the canons of Nicaea, for declaring that Dioscurus had not been condemned at Ephesus on grounds of faith, for replacing the archdeacon Aetius with Andrew, and for alleged leniency toward heretics. The Bollandists examine each of these charges and render a verdict in favour of Anatolius as an orthodox Catholic, saint, and prophet, noting that Pope Saint Leo the Great faulted him not for doctrinal error—though papal legates rejected an initial profession of faith he drafted—but for having permitted himself to be consecrated by a schismatic.12

When Anatolius fell dangerously ill, he was restored to health by Saint Daniel the Stylite, who travelled to Constantinople to visit him. After governing the patriarchate for eight years, Anatolius died in 458, reportedly put to death by Monophysite partisans. His feast is kept on 3 July.12

Remember

  • Born at Alexandria, Saint Anatolius opposed Nestorius at Ephesus and Eutyches at Constantinople before becoming Patriarch of Constantinople under Theodosius II.2
  • Although Dioscurus of Alexandria favoured his appointment, Anatolius condemned Dioscurus and his followers at the Council of Chalcedon (451).1
  • While Baronius criticized him over Constantinopolitan precedence and his consecration, the Bollandists vindicated his orthodoxy, and Pope Leo I blamed him not for doctrinal error but for accepting consecration from a schismatic.12
  • Healed during a grave illness by Saint Daniel the Stylite, Anatolius died in 458 after an eight-year patriarchate (reportedly killed by heretics), and his feast is kept on 3 July.12

Check yourself

Which stylite saint travelled to Constantinople and restored Patriarch Saint Anatolius to health when he was in danger of death?

Feast days and patronage

  • 3 July — Roman and Byzantine Martyrologies (Constantinople and Universal · memorial)

Virtues

Facts and sources

Each fact names its source. The label shows how sure we can be.

  1. The Church status of Saint Anatolius of Constantinople is Saint.

    Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume I: Aachen–Assizevol. I, p. 457 (clean-text lines 77115–77116)

  2. Born at Alexandria, Anatolius opposed Nestorius at Ephesus and Eutyches at Constantinople before serving eight years as Patriarch of Constantinople until 458, condemning Dioscurus at the Council of Chalcedon.

    Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume I: Aachen–Assizevol. I, p. 457 (clean-text lines 77115–77145)

  3. The Bollandists defend Anatolius against the criticisms of Baronius, noting that the Pope blamed him not for doctrinal error but for allowing himself to be consecrated by a schismatic.

    Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume I: Aachen–Assizevol. I, p. 457 (clean-text lines 77123–77139)

  4. When in danger of death, Anatolius was restored to health by Saint Daniel the Stylite, who came to Constantinople to visit him.

    Attributed: A source reports this, but we are not sure it is true or who said itThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume I: Aachen–Assizevol. I, p. 457 (clean-text lines 77146–77149)

  5. Saint Anatolius of Constantinople died in 458 (reportedly put to death by heretics), and his feast is kept on 3 July.

    Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume I: Aachen–Assizevol. I, p. 457 (clean-text lines 77120–77149)

  6. Primary bibliography cited for Pass 2: Acta Sanctorum, 3 July; Smith in Dict. of Christ. Biog.; Hergenröther, Hist. de l'Église, II.

    Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume I: Aachen–Assizevol. I, p. 457 (clean-text lines 77151–77152)

Sources

T. J. Campbell, “Anatolius, Saint,” The Catholic Encyclopedia (1907), vol. I, p. 457. About this source

Notes and sources

About the source edition · T. J. Campbell, The Catholic Encyclopedia (1907), vol. I, p. 457

  1. 1. Anatolius became Patriarch of Constantinople under Theodosius II, condemned Dioscurus at Chalcedon, and died in 458 after eight years in the see (reportedly killed by heretics); Baronius criticized his consecration and jurisdictional claims.

    1. Appointment as Patriarch of Constantinople, condemnation of Dioscurus at Chalcedon, and death in 458Lines 77115–77134

    Original passage

    “Anatolius, Saint, Patriarch of Constantinople in the time of Theodosius the Younger. The lieretic Dioscurus had favoure<l his appointment a.s patriarch, hoping for his support , but he found in Anatolius a determined enemy, who in the Council of Chalcedon condemned him and his followers. How he died is disputed, but it would appear that the heretics put him to death. Baronius says this occurred in 458 after eight years in the patriarchate. The great annalist condemns him in a somewhat violent manner, for conniving with Dioscurus for his appointment to the .see; for demanding in contravention of the statutes of Nica>a, tlie supremacy of Const;intiMo])le over Antioch and Alexandria; for insincerity in o|)pcising a new formula of tloctrine; for declaring that Dioscurus was not condemned at Ephesus, on accoimt of the faith; for removing the meritorious jEtius from the archidiaconate, and naming the unworthy Andrew; for weakness, if not connivance in dealing with the heretics. All of these serious accusations”
  2. 2. The Bollandists defend Anatolius's orthodoxy and sanctity; born at Alexandria, he opposed Nestorius and Eutyches, was healed by Saint Daniel the Stylite, and is commemorated on 3 July. Pass 2 bibliography cited by T. J. Campbell: Acta Sanctorum, 3 July; William Smith in Dictionary of Christian Biography; Joseph Hergenröther, Histoire de l'Église, vol. II.

    2. Vindication by the Bollandists, Pope Leo I's judgment, healing by Daniel the Stylite, and bibliographyLines 77134–77154

    Original passage

    “with the heretics. All of these serious accusations are discussed by the Bollandists, who give a verdict in favour of AnatoliiLs. He is held by thein to he a true Catholic, a .saint, and a prophet. The Pope blamed him, not for error but becau.se he permitted himself to Ix; con.sccrated by a schismatic. One entliusiastic biographer narrates that his miracles and his combats e(|ual in number the sands of the sea. He was born at Alexandria, and before becoming patriarch distinguished liimself at Ephesus against Nestorius, and at Const:mtiiiople against Eutyclies, though the profession of faith which he drew up was rejected by the papal legates. When he w!»s in danger of death he was restored to healtli by St. Daniel the Stylite, who came to Constantinople to see him. His feast is kept 3 July. Aria SS. 3 July; .Smith in Diet, of Chritt, Biog.; Hekoen- RoTllEU, flitl. dc I'tfjlite, II. T. J. Campbell.”

Found an error? Report a correction.