Catholic Saints · Rome
- Canonized Saint
- Feast 13 July
- d. c. 91 at Rome (martyr)
- 1 source

Pope Saint Anacletus (d. c. 91)
Also known as Cletus, Anencletus, Pope Saint Anacletus
How do early papal lists and historians treat Pope Saint Anacletus and Cletus?
Pope Saint Anacletus (also called Cletus or Anencletus, martyred around 91) was the second successor of Saint Peter as Bishop of Rome. Early patristic lists and modern historians identify Anacletus and Cletus as the same pontiff, placing him between Linus and Clement.12
Life and remembrance
Traditional account
Pope Saint Anacletus, the second successor of Saint Peter in the see of Rome, ordained a number of priests in the capital and died a martyr around the year 91. Whether Anacletus was identical with Cletus—also written Anencletus in Greek—has been the subject of long historical debate.12
Saints Irenaeus, Eusebius, Augustine, and Optatus use the names Anacletus and Cletus interchangeably for a single bishop, whereas Tertullian omits him altogether. Their succession order also varies: Irenaeus lists Linus, Anacletus, and Clement, while Augustine and Optatus place Clement before Anacletus. Conversely, the fourth-century Catalogus Liberianus, the Carmen contra Marcionem, and the Liber Pontificalis distinguish Cletus and Anacletus as two separate popes, and the Catalogus Felicianus describes Cletus as a Roman and Anacletus as a Greek.1
Among modern scholars, Cardinal Joseph Hergenröther, the Bollandist Charles De Smedt, Ignaz von Döllinger, and Louis Duchesne conclude that Cletus and Anacletus were one and the same person, while Bernard Jungmann leaves the question open. Following Duchesne's critique of the Liberian Catalogue prior to 230, historians accept Irenaeus's succession list—Linus, Anacletus, Clement, Evaristus, Alexander, Xystus, Telesphorus, Hyginus, Pius, and Anicetus—even though exact regnal years and months before Anicetus (who reigned in 154) cannot be fixed with certainty.2
Remember
- Pope Saint Anacletus (also called Cletus or Anencletus) was the second successor of Saint Peter, ordained priests in Rome, and died a martyr around 91.12
- Irenaeus, Eusebius, Augustine, and Optatus treat Anacletus and Cletus as one person, with Irenaeus giving the order Linus, Anacletus, Clement.1
- The Catalogus Liberianus, Carmen contra Marcionem, Liber Pontificalis, and Catalogus Felicianus divide Cletus and Anacletus into two distinct pontiffs.1
- Modern historians including Hergenröther, De Smedt, Döllinger, and Duchesne affirm the identity of Cletus and Anacletus and adopt Irenaeus's papal list.2
Check yourself
Which four patristic writers use the names Cletus and Anacletus interchangeably for a single Bishop of Rome, and which three ancient documents treat them as two distinct popes?
Feast days and patronage
- 13 July — General Roman Calendar (1907, 13 July) (Universal · memorial)
Virtues
Facts and sources
Each fact names its source. The label shows how sure we can be.
The Church status of Pope Saint Anacletus is Saint.
Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume I: Aachen–Assizevol. I, pp. 446–447 (clean-text lines 75339–75340)
Pope Saint Anacletus (also called Cletus or Anencletus) was the second successor of Saint Peter as Bishop of Rome, ordained priests, and died a martyr around 91.
Attributed: A source reports this, but we are not sure it is true or who said itThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume I: Aachen–Assizevol. I, pp. 446–447 (clean-text lines 75339–75377)
Irenaeus, Eusebius, Augustine, and Optatus treat Cletus and Anacletus as one person (with Irenaeus listing Linus, Anacletus, Clement), whereas the Catalogus Liberianus, Carmen contra Marcionem, Liber Pontificalis, and Catalogus Felicianus distinguish them.
Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume I: Aachen–Assizevol. I, pp. 446–447 (clean-text lines 75340–75356)
Modern historians Hergenröther, De Smedt, Döllinger, and Duchesne conclude that Cletus and Anacletus were the same person and follow Irenaeus's succession list.
Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume I: Aachen–Assizevol. I, pp. 446–447 (clean-text lines 75356–75374)
Pope Saint Anacletus is commemorated on 13 July in Butler's Lives of the Saints and Acta Sanctorum (July, vol. III).
Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume I: Aachen–Assizevol. I, pp. 446–447 (clean-text lines 75379–75382)
Primary bibliography cited for Pass 2: Acta Sanctorum, July, III; Hergenröther, Hist. de l'Église, I; Jungmann, Dissert. Hist. Eccl., I; De Smedt, Dissert., I; Duchesne, Origines chrétiennes; Butler, Lives of the Saints (13 July).
Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume I: Aachen–Assizevol. I, pp. 446–447 (clean-text lines 75379–75382)
Sources
T. J. Campbell, “Anacletus, Saint,” The Catholic Encyclopedia (1907), vol. I, pp. 446–447. About this source
Notes and sources
About the source edition · T. J. Campbell, The Catholic Encyclopedia (1907), vol. I, pp. 446–447
1. Anacletus (Cletus or Anencletus), second successor of Peter, is treated as one person by Irenaeus, Eusebius, Augustine, and Optatus, whereas the Catalogus Liberianus, Carmen contra Marcionem, Liber Pontificalis, and Catalogus Felicianus split him into two popes.
1. Identity with Cletus and patristic versus catalogue traditionsLines 75339–75356
Original passage
“Anacletus, Saint and Pope, was the second successor of St. Peter. Whether he was the same as Cletus, who is also called Anencletus as well as Anacletus, has been the subject of endless discussion. Irenjeus, Eusebius, Augustine, Optatus, use both names indifferently as of one person. TertuUian omits him altogether. To add to the confusion, the order is different. Thus Irena^us has Linus, Anacletus, Clement; whereas Augustine and Optatus put Clement before Anacletus. On the other hand, the "Catalogus Liberianus", the "Carmen contra Marcionem" and the "Liber Pontificalis ", all most respectable for their antiquity, make Cletus and Anacletus distinct from each other; while the "Catalogus Felicianus" even sets the latter down as a Greek, the former as a Roman. Among the moderns, Hergenrother (Hist, de I'dglise, I, 542, note) pronounces for their identity. So also the BoUandist De Smedt (Dissert.,”
2. Hergenröther, De Smedt, Döllinger, and Duchesne affirm the identity of Cletus and Anacletus and follow Irenaeus's succession list; Anacletus ordained priests and died a martyr around 91. Pass 2 bibliography cited by T. J. Campbell: Acta Sanctorum, July, III; Hergenröther, Histoire de l'Église, I, 542; Jungmann, Dissertationes Selectae in Historiam Ecclesiasticam, I, 123; De Smedt, Dissertationes, VII, 1; Duchesne, Origines chrétiennes; Alban Butler, Lives of the Saints (13 July).
2. Judgments of Hergenröther, De Smedt, Döllinger, Duchesne, and Jungmann, martyrdom c. 91, and bibliographyLines 75356–75384
Original passage
“identity. So also the BoUandist De Smedt (Dissert., vii, 1). DoUinger (Christenth. u K., 315) declares that "they are, without doubt, the same person"; and that "the 'Catalogue of Liberius' merits little confidence before 230." Duchesne, " Origines clir6- tiennes", ranges himself on that side also; but Jungmann (Dissert. Hist. Eed., I, 123) leaves the question in doubt. The chronology is, of course, in consetiuence of all this, very imdetermined, but Duchesne, in his "Origines", says "we are far from the day when the years, months, and days of the Pontifical C:italogue can be gi\on with any guarantee of exactness. But is it necessary to be exact about popes of whom wo know so little? We can accept the list of Irena>us, Linus, Anacletus, Clement, Evaristus, Alexander, Xystus, Telesphorus, Hygimis, Pius, and Anicetus. Anicetus reigned iort;iinly in 154. That is all we can .say with assurance about primitive pontifical chronology." That he ordained a certain number of priests is nearly all we have of positive record about liiiu, but we know he died a martyr, perhaps about 91. AcUt SS., July, III; lIUHOF.NBaTHKR, Iliat. de Kglitie. I; JuNGMANN, IHaseTt. lliitt. KccL, 1; Dk Smkdt, Duiaert., I; DucMKsNE, Originta chrtlicnnta; BuTLKii, Lives of the Satnta, 13 July. T. J. Campbell.”
Found an error? Report a correction.
