Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Catholic Saints · Comana in Pontus (near Neo-Caesarea)

  • Canonized Saint
  • Feast 11 August
  • d. c. 250–251, Comana in Pontus
  • 1 source
Mosaic portrait of Saint Alexander of Comana

Saint Alexander of Comana (c. 250–251)

Also known as Alexander the Charcoal Burner, Alexander Carbonarius

Why did Saint Gregory Thaumaturgus choose Alexander the Charcoal Burner as Bishop of Comana?

Saint Alexander of Comana, known as the Charcoal Burner because he practised that humble trade to shun worldly honours, was chosen Bishop of Comana in Pontus by Saint Gregory Thaumaturgus and was burned to death for the Christian faith during the persecution of Decius.12

Life and remembrance

Saint Alexander, known as "the Charcoal Burner," was Bishop of Comana in Pontus, near Neo-Caesarea. Out of humility and a desire to escape worldly honours, he took up the trade of burning charcoal, practicing a Christian philosophy that preferred heavenly things to earthly distinction.1

His hidden sanctity came to light when Saint Gregory Thaumaturgus was invited to Comana to assist in selecting a bishop for the city. After Gregory rejected all the candidates proposed to him, a bystander suggested in derision that he might as well choose Alexander the charcoal burner. Taking the remark seriously, Gregory summoned Alexander, discovered his holiness and spiritual capability, and consecrated him Bishop of Comana.1

Alexander governed the diocese with wisdom and ultimately gave his life for the Christian faith, being burned to death during the persecution of Emperor Decius. His election is preserved through a discourse by Saint Gregory of Nyssa on the life of Saint Gregory Thaumaturgus, and his feast is observed on 11 August, where he is styled a philosophus disertissimus (most eloquent philosopher).2

Other accounts and ways this saint is remembered

The Bollandists (Acta Sanctorum, August, II) examine the several ancient cities named Comana and identify Alexander's see with Comana in Pontus, near Neo-Caesarea, while leaving open whether he was its first bishop.1

Although absent from the oldest Greek and Roman calendars, Alexander is known from Saint Gregory of Nyssa's panegyric on the life of Saint Gregory Thaumaturgus and is inscribed in the modern Roman Martyrology under 11 August as a 'philosophus disertissimus'.2

Remember

  • Saint Alexander of Comana worked as a charcoal burner in Pontus near Neo-Caesarea out of humility in order to avoid worldly honours.1
  • When Saint Gregory Thaumaturgus rejected the proposed episcopal candidates at Comana and someone derisively named Alexander, Gregory summoned him and consecrated him bishop.1
  • After governing the see of Comana with wisdom, Alexander was burned to death for the faith during the persecution of Decius.2
  • His election is recorded in Saint Gregory of Nyssa's discourse on Saint Gregory Thaumaturgus, and his feast is kept on 11 August.2

Check yourself

How did Saint Gregory Thaumaturgus come to summon and consecrate Saint Alexander as Bishop of Comana, and how did Alexander die under Emperor Decius?

Feast days and patronage

  • 11 August — Roman Martyrology (Rome and universal Church · memorial)

Facts and sources

Each fact names its source. The label shows how sure we can be.

  1. The Church status of Saint Alexander of Comana is Saint.

    Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume I: Aachen–Assizevol. I, pp. 295–296 (clean-text lines 51247–51249)

  2. Saint Alexander of Comana in Pontus (near Neo-Caesarea) worked as a charcoal burner out of humility to escape worldly honours.

    Attributed: A source reports this, but we are not sure it is true or who said itThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume I: Aachen–Assizevol. I, pp. 295–296 (clean-text lines 51247–51260)

  3. When Saint Gregory Thaumaturgus rejected the candidates for the bishopric of Comana and someone suggested Alexander in derision, Gregory summoned him, recognized his sanctity, and made him bishop.

    Attributed: A source reports this, but we are not sure it is true or who said itThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume I: Aachen–Assizevol. I, pp. 295–296 (clean-text lines 51260–51270)

  4. After administering the see of Comana with wisdom, Alexander was burned to death during the persecution of Decius.

    Attributed: A source reports this, but we are not sure it is true or who said itThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume I: Aachen–Assizevol. I, pp. 295–296 (clean-text lines 51269–51273)

  5. Known through Saint Gregory of Nyssa's discourse on Saint Gregory Thaumaturgus, Alexander of Comana is commemorated on 11 August as a philosophus disertissimus (Acta Sanctorum, August, II).

    Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume I: Aachen–Assizevol. I, pp. 295–296 (clean-text lines 51273–51286)

Sources

T. J. Campbell, “Alexander, Saint,” The Catholic Encyclopedia (1907), vol. I, pp. 295–296. About this source

Notes and sources

About the source edition · T. J. Campbell, The Catholic Encyclopedia (1907), vol. I, pp. 295–296

  1. 1. The Bollandists (Acta SS., August, II) locate Alexander's see at Comana in Pontus near Neo-Caesarea and discuss whether he was its first bishop.

    1. See of Comana in Pontus, charcoal-burning trade, and selection by Gregory ThaumaturgusLines 51247–51271

    Original passage

    “Alexander, Saint, known as "The charcoal burner," was Bishop of Comana, in Pontua. Whether he was the first to occupy that see is open to discussion. The Bollandists have also a long paper as to the exact location of Comaua as there were several places of that name, but decide for Pontus, near Neo-Ca-sarea. The curious name of the saint corner from the fact that he had, out of humility, taken up the work of burning charcoal, so as to escape worldly honours. He is called a philosopher, but it is not certain that the term is to be taken literally. His philosophy consisted rather in his preference of heavenly to earthly things. The discovery of his virtues was due to the very contempt with which he had been regarded. St. Gregory Thaumaturgus had been asked to come to Comana tohelp select a bishop for that place. As he rejected all the candidates, .some one in derision suggested that he might accept Alexander the charcoal-burner. Gregory took the suggestion seriously, summoned Alexander, and found that he had to do with a saint, and a man of great capabilities. Alexander was made bishop of the see, administered it with remarkable wisdom, and ultimately gave up his life”
  2. 2. Alexander's election is preserved exclusively in Saint Gregory of Nyssa's discourse on Saint Gregory Thaumaturgus; the modern Roman Martyrology lists him on 11 August as philosophus disertissimus. Cited bibliography for Pass 2: Acta Sanctorum, August, II; Saint Gregory of Nyssa, Life of Saint Gregory Thaumaturgus.

    2. Martyrdom by fire under Decius, Gregory of Nyssa's discourse, and 11 August feastLines 51271–51287

    Original passage

    “wisdom, and ultimately gave up his life for the Faith, being burned to death in the persecution of Decius. The vagueness of the information we have about him comes from the fact that his name is not found in any of the old Greek or Roman calendars. He would have been absolutely unknown were it not for a discourse pronounced by St. Gregory .of Nyssa, on the life of St. Gregory Thaumaturgus, in which the election of Alexander is incidentally described. In the modern Roman Martyrology his ■ name occurs, and he is described as a " philosophus disertissimus." His feast is kept on 11 August. AcUt Sanctorum, August I. rn x <-. T. J. Campbell.”

Found an error? Report a correction.