Catholic Saints · Rome
- Canonized Saint
- Feast 3 May
- d. c. 115 or 116, Rome
- 1 source

Pope Saint Alexander I (d. c. 115)
Also known as Alexander I
How do early episcopal lists and fifth-century Roman traditions describe Pope Saint Alexander I?
Pope Saint Alexander I governed the Roman Church for about ten years under Emperor Trajan (dated 106–115 by Duchesne and 109–116 by Lightfoot) as fifth successor of the Apostles in the list of Saint Irenaeus, while fifth-century Roman tradition associates him with martyrdom on the Via Nomentana.1
Life and remembrance
Traditional account
Writing in the final quarter of the second century, Saint Irenaeus of Lyons reckons Pope Saint Alexander I as the fifth bishop of Rome in succession from the Apostles, without mentioning a martyrdom. His pontificate, placed in the reign of Emperor Trajan (98–117), lasted about ten years according to Eusebius (Historia Ecclesiastica, IV, i), was included in the Roman episcopal catalogue drawn up by Hegesippus before the death of Pope Eleutherius (c. 189; Eusebius, IV, xxii, 3), and is dated 106–115 by Louis Duchesne and 109–116 by J. B. Lightfoot.1
According to a tradition current in the Roman Church at the close of the fifth century and recorded in the Liber Pontificalis, Alexander was a Roman by birth who suffered martyrdom by decapitation on the Via Nomentana on 3 May. The Liber Pontificalis also attributes to him the insertion into the Canon of the Mass of the Qui pridie formula commemorating the institution of the Eucharist—words that belong to the primitive core of the Roman rite—as well as the custom of blessing water mixed with salt to purify Christian dwellings from evil influences (constituit aquam sparsionis cum sale benedici in habitaculis hominum), an early Roman blessing preserved in the Gelasian Sacramentary that closely parallels the liturgical Asperges prayer.12
In 1855 a semi-subterranean cemetery of the martyrs Alexander, Eventulus, and Theodulus was discovered near Rome on the Via Nomentana at the site indicated by the fifth-century tradition. Some archaeologists identified the martyr buried there with Pope Alexander I, whereas Duchesne maintained that an ancient confusion before the sixth century merged the Via Nomentana martyr with the second-century pope. In 834 relics attributed to Alexander I were translated to Freising in Bavaria.23
Other accounts and ways this saint is remembered
While archaeologists who excavated the semi-subterranean cemetery of Saints Alexander, Eventulus, and Theodulus on the Via Nomentana in 1855 identified the tomb as that of Pope Alexander I, Louis Duchesne (Liber Pontificalis, I, xci–xcii) and Albert Dufourcq (Gesta Martyrum Romains, 1900, 210–211) argue that the Roman martyr Alexander was conflated with the second-century pope before the compilation of the Liber Pontificalis in the early sixth century.2
Chronological objections concerning the earliest successors of Saint Peter raised by Richard Lipsius (Chronologie der römischen Bischöfe, Kiel, 1869) and Adolf Harnack (Die Zeit des Ignatius, 1878) are examined by Cardinal Francesco Segna (De successione priorum Romanorum Pontificum, Rome, 1897), J. B. Lightfoot (Apostolic Fathers: St. Clement, London, 1890, I, 201–345), and Louis Duchesne (Liber Pontificalis, Paris, 1886, I, i–xlviii, lxviii–lxxiii).3
Spurious letters attributed to Alexander I by Pseudo-Isidore are printed in Migne (Patrologia Graeca, V, 1057 sq.) and Paul Hinschius (Decretales Pseudo-Isidorianae, Leipzig, 1863, 94–105), and his unauthentic later Acts are discussed by Tillemont (Mémoires, II, 590 sqq.).3
Remember
- Saint Irenaeus of Lyons counts Alexander I as the fifth bishop of Rome after the Apostles, and Eusebius credits him with a ten-year pontificate under Emperor Trajan (dated 106–115 or 109–116).1
- Late fifth-century Roman tradition in the Liber Pontificalis describes him as a native Roman beheaded on the Via Nomentana on 3 May.1
- The Liber Pontificalis attributes to him the Qui pridie Eucharistic words and the blessing of water mixed with salt for Christian homes.2
- A cemetery of Saints Alexander, Eventulus, and Theodulus was unearthed on the Via Nomentana in 1855, though Duchesne distinguishes that martyr from the pope; relics were translated to Freising in 834.23
Check yourself
Which liturgical blessing for Christian homes and which prayer in the Canon of the Mass does the Liber Pontificalis attribute to Pope Saint Alexander I?
Writings and words
- Decretal Letters Ascribed to Pope Alexander I (Pseudo-Isidore)Coming soon · Not written by this author
Feast days and patronage
- 3 May — General Roman Calendar (commemorated with Eventulus and Theodulus) (Rome (Via Nomentana) · memorial)
Facts and sources
Each fact names its source. The label shows how sure we can be.
The Church status of Pope Saint Alexander I is Saint.
Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume I: Aachen–Assizevol. I, pp. 285–286 (clean-text lines 49590–49591)
Saint Irenaeus of Lyons reckons Alexander I as the fifth pope in succession from the Apostles, and his ten-year pontificate under Trajan is dated 106–115 by Duchesne and 109–116 by Lightfoot.
Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume I: Aachen–Assizevol. I, pp. 285–286 (clean-text lines 49590–49601)
Late fifth-century Roman tradition in the Liber Pontificalis describes Alexander I as a native Roman who was beheaded on the Via Nomentana on 3 May.
Tradition: A story passed down through faith or recorded laterThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume I: Aachen–Assizevol. I, pp. 285–286 (clean-text lines 49601–49608)
The Liber Pontificalis attributes to Alexander I the Qui pridie Eucharistic words in the Canon of the Mass and the blessing of water mixed with salt for Christian homes.
Attributed: A source reports this, but we are not sure it is true or who said itThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume I: Aachen–Assizevol. I, pp. 285–286 (clean-text lines 49608–49621)
In 1855 a cemetery of Saints Alexander, Eventulus, and Theodulus was discovered on the Via Nomentana; Duchesne distinguishes that martyr from Pope Alexander I, whose relics were reportedly translated to Freising in 834.
Disputed: Reliable sources disagreeThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume I: Aachen–Assizevol. I, pp. 285–286 (clean-text lines 49621–49656)
Primary and secondary authorities include Duchesne's Liber Pontificalis (I, xci–xcii, 127), Acta Sanctorum (May, I, 375 sqq.), De Rossi (1865), Lightfoot (1890), Segna (1897), and Dufourcq (1900).
Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume I: Aachen–Assizevol. I, pp. 285–286 (clean-text lines 49635–49661)
Sources
Thomas J. Shahan, “Alexander I, Saint,” The Catholic Encyclopedia (1907), vol. I, pp. 285–286. About this source
Notes and sources
About the source edition · Thomas J. Shahan, The Catholic Encyclopedia (1907), vol. I, pp. 285–286
1. Shahan contrasts the second-century witness of Irenaeus and Hegesippus (via Eusebius) with the late fifth-century Roman tradition recorded in the Liber Pontificalis.
1. Succession in Irenaeus, Hegesippus, and Eusebius; dating by Duchesne and LightfootLines 49590–49608
Original passage
“Alexander I, Saint, Pope. — St. Irenseus of Lyons, writing in the latter quarter of the second century, reckons him as the fifth pope in succession from the .\postles, though he says nothing of his martyrdom. His pontificate is variouslv dated by critics, e. g. lOC-115 (Duchesne) or 109-116 (Lightfoot). In Christian antiquity he was credited with a pontificate of about ten years (Eusebius, Hist. Eccl., IV, i,) and there is no reason to doubt that he was on the "catalogue of bishops" drawn up at Rome by Hegesippus (Eusebius, I\ , xxii, 3) before the death of Pope Eleutherius (c. 189). According to a tradition extant in the Roman Church at the end of the fifth century, and recorded in the Liber Pontificalis, he suffered a martyr's death by decapitation on the Via Nomentana in Rome, 3 May. The same tradition declares him to have been a Roman by birth, and to have ruled the Church in the reign of Trajan (98-117). It likewise attributes to him, but scarcely”
2. Duchesne (Lib. Pont., I, xci–xcii, 127) and Dufourcq (Gesta Martyrum Romains, 210–211) hold that the identification of the Via Nomentana martyr Alexander with Pope Alexander I arose from an ancient pre-sixth-century conflation.
2. Liber Pontificalis attributions (Qui pridie, blessed water and salt) and Via Nomentana cemeteryLines 49608–49635
Original passage
“(98-117). It likewise attributes to him, but scarcely with accuracy, the insertion in the canon of the Qui Pridic, or words commemorative of the institution of the Eucharist, such lx;ing certainly primitive and original in the Mass. He is also said to ha\e introduced the use of blessing water mixed with salt for the purification of Christian homes from evil influences (constituit aquam sparsionis cum sale benedici in habitaculis hominum). Duchesne (Lib. Pont., I, 127) calls attention to the persistence of this early Roman custom by way of a blessing in the Gelasian Sacramenfarj' that recalls ver\' forcibly the actual -■Vsix^rges prayer at the l)oginning of Ma.ss. In 18.55. a semi-subterranean cemeterj- of the holy martjTS Sts. Alexander, Eventulus, and Theodulus was discovered near Rome, at the spot where the above mentioned tradition declares the Pope to have been martyred. .According to some archa-ologist.'s. this Alexander is identical with the Pope, and this ancient and important tomb marks the actual site of the Pope's martyrdom. Duchesne, however (op. cit., I, xci-ii) denies the identity of the martyr and tlie pope, while admittmg that tlie confusion of both personages is of ancient date, probably anterior to the beginning of the si.xth century, when the Liber Pontificalis was first compiled [Dufourcq, C.esta Martyrum Romains (Paris, 1900), 210-211], The difficulties raised in recent”
3. The letters in Pseudo-Isidore (P.G., V, 1057 sq.; Hinschius, 94–105) and the later Acts are spurious. Cited bibliography for Pass 2: Liber Pontificalis (ed. Duchesne), I, xci–xcii, 127; Duchesne, Histoire ancienne de l'Église (Paris, 1906), 236–237; Acta SS., May, I, 375 sqq.; Atti del martirio di S. Alessandro (Rome, 1855); De Rossi, Bullettino di archeologia cristiana (Rome, 1865); Segna, De successione priorum Romanorum Pontificum (Rome, 1897); Lightfoot, Apostolic Fathers: St. Clement (London, 1890), I, 201–345; Dümmler, Poetae Latini Aevi Carolini (Berlin, 1884), II, 120; Tillemont, Mémoires, II, 590 sqq.
3. Modern chronological scholarship, Pseudo-Isidorian letters, Freising translation, and bibliographyLines 49635–49663
Original passage
“1900), 210-211], The difficulties raised in recent times by Richard Lipsius (Chronologie der romischen Bischofe, Kiel, 1869) and Adolph Harnack (Die Zeit des Ignatius u. die Chronologie der antiochenischen Bischofe. 187S) concerning the earliest successors of St. Peter are ably discussed and answered by F. S. (Canlinal Francesco Segna) in his "De successione priorum Romanoruni Pontificum" (Rome 1897); with moderation and learning by Bishop Lightfoot, in his "ApostoHc Fathers: St. Clement" (London, 1890) I, 201-345; especially by Duchesne in the introduction to his edition of the "Liber Pontificalis" (Paris, 1886) I, i-xlviii and Ixviii-lxxiii. The letters ascribed to Alexander I by Pseudo- Isidore may be seen in P. G., V, 1057 sq., and in Hinschius, " Decretales Pseudo-Isidorianse " (Leipzig, 1863) 94-105. His remains are said to have been transferred to Freising in Bavaria in 834 (Dilmmler, Poeta; Latini Aevi Carolini, Berlin, 1884, II, 120). His so-called "Acts" are not genuine, and were compiled at a much later date (Tillemont, Mem. II, 590 sqq; Dufourcq, op. cit., 210-211). Liber Pontificalis (erl. Duchesne). I, xci-ii. 127, Hist. Ancienne de VEglite (Paris, 1906). 236-237; Acta SS., May 1, 375 sqq.; Atti del mnrtirio diS. Alessandro, etc. (Rome, 1855); De Kossi, Btillettino di archeologia cristiana (Rome. 1865), Thomas J. Sh.\h.\n.”
Found an error? Report a correction.
