Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Catholic Saints · Rome

  • Canonized Saint
  • Feast 20 September
  • d. 21 April 536
  • 1 source
Mosaic portrait of Pope Saint Agapetus I

Pope Saint Agapetus I (d. 536)

Also known as Agapitus I, Pope Agapetus I, Saint Agapitus

How did Pope Saint Agapetus I oppose the Monophysite intruder Anthimus at Constantinople?

Pope Saint Agapetus I (also spelled Agapitus; reigned 535–536, died 21 April 536), son of the martyred Roman priest Gordianus, governed the Roman Church for ten months. Sent by the Ostrogothic king Theodahad on an embassy to Emperor Justinian at Constantinople, he deposed the Monophysite intruder Anthimus and consecrated Mennas as patriarch.12

Life and remembrance

Traditional account

Pope Saint Agapetus I (also spelled Agapitus) reigned from 535 until his death on 21 April 536. His birth date is unknown; he was the son of Gordianus, a Roman priest killed during the street violence of the pontificate of Pope Symmachus. In his first official act as pope, Agapetus assembled the Roman clergy and burned the document of anathema that Pope Boniface II had issued against his deceased rival Dioscurus and deposited in the Roman archives.1

In Western ecclesiastical affairs, Agapetus confirmed the decrees enacted by the Council of Carthage after the liberation of North Africa from Vandal rule, declaring converts from Arianism ineligible for sacred orders and admitting former Arian clergy only to lay communion. When Bishop Contumeliosus of Riez appealed his condemnation for immorality by a council at Marseilles, Agapetus accepted the appeal and directed Saint Caesarius of Arles to grant the accused bishop a new trial before papal delegates.1

After the Byzantine general Belisarius conquered Sicily and prepared to invade mainland Italy, the Ostrogothic king Theodahad implored the aged pontiff to travel to Constantinople and persuade Emperor Justinian to abandon the campaign. To cover the expenses of the legation, Agapetus had to pledge the sacred vessels of the Roman Church. Setting out in midwinter with five bishops and a large retinue, he entered Constantinople in February 536 and was received with high honours, though Justinian refused to halt his military effort to restore imperial rule in Italy.2

In ecclesiastical matters, however, Agapetus’s presence in the eastern capital proved decisive. With the backing of Empress Theodora, Bishop Anthimus had uncanonically abandoned his see of Trebizond to join the crypto-Monophysite party working against the Council of Chalcedon, and the empress had seated him on the patriarchal throne of Constantinople over the protests of the orthodox clergy. Immediately upon Agapetus’s arrival, leading clerics formally charged Anthimus as an intruder and heretic. Agapetus ordered Anthimus to submit a written profession of orthodox faith and return to Trebizond, refusing all communion with him until he complied.2

Deceived by Theodora regarding her favourite’s orthodoxy, Emperor Justinian threatened Agapetus with banishment, prompting the pope’s famous reply: “With eager longing have I come to gaze upon the Most Christian Emperor Justinian. In his place I find a Diocletian, whose threats, however, terrify me not.” Struck by the pope’s firmness and convinced at length that Anthimus was heterodox, Justinian withdrew his opposition. Exercising the fullness of papal authority, Agapetus deposed and suspended Anthimus and—for the first time in Church history—personally consecrated his canonically elected successor, Mennas, as Patriarch of Constantinople.2

To clear himself of any suspicion of favouring heresy, Justinian presented the pope with a written profession of faith, which Agapetus accepted with the proviso that “although he could not admit in a layman the right of teaching religion, yet he observed with pleasure that the zeal of the Emperor was in perfect accord with the decisions of the Fathers.” Falling ill shortly afterward, Agapetus died at Constantinople on 21 April 536 after a reign of ten months. His body was carried back to Rome in a leaden coffin and buried in Saint Peter’s Basilica; the Latin Church keeps his feast on 20 September, the day of his deposition, while the Greeks commemorate him on 22 April.3

Remember

  • Pope Saint Agapetus I (reigned 535–536, died 21 April 536) was the son of Gordianus, a Roman priest slain during the riots under Pope Symmachus.1
  • Upon taking office he burned Boniface II’s posthumous anathema against Dioscurus, confirmed the African council decrees on former Arians, and ordered Caesarius of Arles to retry Bishop Contumeliosus of Riez.1
  • Pledging the sacred vessels of the Roman Church to finance a winter embassy for King Theodahad, he arrived in Constantinople in February 536 to negotiate with Emperor Justinian.2
  • Defying Justinian’s threats of exile, Agapetus deposed the crypto-Monophysite intruder Anthimus and personally consecrated Mennas as Patriarch of Constantinople.2
  • His remains were returned to Saint Peter’s Basilica in a leaden coffin; his feast is kept on 20 September in the West and 22 April in the East.3

Check yourself

How did Pope Saint Agapetus I finance his winter journey to Constantinople, and what action did he take against Patriarch Anthimus?

Feast days and patronage

  • 20 September — Latin Church (day of deposition) (Rome / Latin Church · memorial)
  • 22 April — Greek Church (Eastern Churches · memorial)

Facts and sources

Each fact names its source. The label shows how sure we can be.

  1. The Church status of Pope Saint Agapetus I is Saint.

    Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume I: Aachen–Assizevol. I, pp. 200–203 (clean-text lines 36078–36080)

  2. Pope Saint Agapetus I (also spelled Agapitus), son of the Roman priest Gordianus, reigned from 535 until his death on 21 April 536.

    Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume I: Aachen–Assizevol. I, pp. 200–203 (clean-text lines 36078–36081)

  3. Agapetus I burned the anathema of Boniface II against Dioscurus, confirmed the Council of Carthage’s exclusion of converted Arians from Holy Orders, and ordered Saint Caesarius of Arles to grant Bishop Contumeliosus of Riez a new trial before papal delegates.

    Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume I: Aachen–Assizevol. I, pp. 200–203 (clean-text lines 36082–36095)

  4. Sent by the Ostrogothic king Theodahad to intercede with Emperor Justinian against Belisarius’s invasion of Italy, Agapetus I pledged the sacred vessels of the Roman Church and arrived in Constantinople with five bishops in February 536.

    Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume I: Aachen–Assizevol. I, pp. 200–203 (clean-text lines 36096–36111)

  5. In Constantinople Agapetus I withstood Justinian’s threat of banishment, deposed the crypto-Monophysite intruder Anthimus, and personally consecrated Mennas as Patriarch of Constantinople.

    Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume I: Aachen–Assizevol. I, pp. 200–203 (clean-text lines 36114–36142)

  6. Agapetus I accepted Emperor Justinian’s written profession of faith while reserving the right of teaching religion from laymen.

    Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume I: Aachen–Assizevol. I, pp. 200–203 (clean-text lines 36144–36153)

  7. After dying at Constantinople on 21 April 536, Agapetus I was buried in Saint Peter’s Basilica in Rome; his feast is kept on 20 September in the Latin Church and on 22 April in the Greek Church. Primary sources include Liber Pontificalis (ed. Duchesne, I, 287–289) and Acta Sanctorum (Sept. VI, 163–179).

    Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume I: Aachen–Assizevol. I, pp. 200–203 (clean-text lines 36153–36163)

Sources

James F. Loughlin, “Agapetus I (also Ag.\pitus), Saint,” The Catholic Encyclopedia (1907), vol. I, pp. 200–203. About this source

Notes and sources

About the source edition · James F. Loughlin, The Catholic Encyclopedia (1907), vol. I, pp. 200–203

  1. 1. Agapetus I reversed Boniface II’s archival condemnation of Dioscurus, upheld the North African synodal discipline barring former Arians from sacred orders, and intervened in the appellate case of Bishop Contumeliosus of Riez.

    1. Parentage, burning of the anathema against Dioscurus, and African and Gallic rulingsLines 36078–36095

    Original passage

    “Agapetus I (also Ag.\pitus), Saint, Pope (53.5- 536), date of birth uncertain; d. 21.' April, 536. He was the son of Gordianus, a Roman priest who had been slain during the riots in the days of Pope Symmachus. His first official act was to bum in the presence of the assembled clergy the anathema which Boniface II (q. v.) had pronounced against the latter's rival Dioscurus and had ordered to be preserved in the Roman archives. He confirmed the decrees of the council held at Carthage, after the liberation of Africa from the \'andal yoke, according to which converts from Arianism were declared ineligible to Holy Orders and those already ordained were merely admitted to lay communion. He accepted an appeal from Contimieliosus, Bishop of Riez, whom a council at Marseilles had condemned for immorality, and he ordered St. Csesarius of Aries to grant the accused a new trial before papal delegates.”
  2. 2. Pledging the Roman Church’s sacred vessels to travel in midwinter, Agapetus reached Constantinople in February 536, withstood Justinian’s threat of exile, deposed Anthimus of Trebizond, and consecrated Mennas.

    2. Embassy for King Theodahad and confrontation with Anthimus and JustinianLines 36096–36144

    Original passage

    “Meanwhile Bclisarius, after the very easy conquest of Sicily, was preparing for an invasion of Italy. The Gothic king, Theodeliad, as a last resort, begged the aged pontiff to proceed to Constantinople and bring his personal influence to bear on the Emperor Justinian. To defray the costs of the embassy, Agapetus was compelled to pledge the sacred vessels of the Church of Rome. He set out in midwinter with five bishops and an imposing retinue. In February, 536, he appeareil in the capital of the East and was received with all tlie honours befitting the head of the Catliolic Church. As he no doubt had foreseen, tlie ostcnsilile object of his visit wa.s doomed to failure. Justinian could not be swerved from his resolve to re-establish the rights of the ICmpire in Italy. But from the ecclesiastical standpoint, the visit of the Pope in Constantinople issued in a triumph scarcely less memorable than the campaigns of Belisarius. 'fhe then occupant of the Byzantine See was a certain Anthimus, who without the authority of the canons had left his episcopal see of Trebizond to join the crj'pto-Monopliysites who, in conjunction with the Knipress Theodora were then intriguing to untleniiiiie (lie authority of the Council of Chaloeddn. Against the protests of the orthodox, the Kinpress finally scaled Anthimus in the patriarchal chair. No sooner had the Pope arrived tlian the most prominent of the clcrgj' entered charges against the new patriarch as an intruder and a heretic. Agapctu-s ordered him to make a written profession of faith and to return to his forsaken see; upon his refusal, he declined to have any relations with him. This vexed the Kmperor, who hail been deceived by his wife as to the orthotloxy of her favourite, and he went so far as to threaten the Pope with banishment. Agapetus replied with spirit: " With eager longing have 1 come to gaze upon tlie Most Christian Emperor Justinian. In his place I find a Diocletian, whose threats, however, terrify me not." This intrepid language made Justinian pause; and being finally convinced tliat Anthimus was unsound in faith, he made no objection to the Pope's exercising the plenitude of his powers in deposing and suspending the intruder and, for the first time in the history of the Church, personally consecrating his legally elected successor, Mennas. This memorable exercise of the papal prerogative was not soon forgotten by the Orientals, who, together with the Latins, venerate him as a saint. In”
  3. 3. Primary and secondary sources cited for Pass 2 expansion: Liber Pontificalis (ed. Louis Duchesne), I, 287–289; Cleus in Acta Sanctorum, Sept. VI, 163–179; Artaud de Montor, Lives of the Popes (New York, 1867), I, 123–124.

    3. Justinian’s profession of faith, death of Agapetus, burial in Saint Peter’s, and bibliographyLines 36144–36165

    Original passage

    “with the Latins, venerate him as a saint. In order to clear himself of everj' suspicion of abetting heresy, Justinian delivered to the Pope a written profession of faith, which the latter accepted with tlie judicious proviso that " although he could not ailmit in a layman the right of teaching religion, yet he observed with pleasure that the zeal of the Em- feror was in perfect accord with the decisions of the athers ". Shortly afterwards .\gapctus fell ill and tlied, after a gloriovis reign of ten months. His remains were brought in a leaden coffin to Rome and deposited in St. Peter's. His memory is kept on 20 September, the day of his deposition. The Greeks commemorate him on 22 April, the day of his death. Lihrr Ponlificalis (ed. DtrcHESNE), I, 287-289; Cleus in Aria SS., Sept., VI, 163-179; AitTACU de iloNTon, Liva of the Popct (New York, 1807). 1, 123. 124. J.\MES F. LOUGHLIN.”

Found an error? Report a correction.