Chapter V · Location 5 of 10
Chapter 5 · Open to readFrom 1 Esdras · Douay–Rheims / Challoner (1749–1752)
How did the temple work continue while the governors questioned its authority?
Atlas of Saints · Chapter summary
The elders cited Cyrus’s decree, the governors referred the matter to Darius, and the builders continued while the archive search and royal decision were pending.
Chapter breakdown
The prophets Aggeus and Zacharias the son of Addo began to prophesy to the Jewish people residing in Judea and Jerusalem, speaking in the name of the God of Israel. Prompted by their message, Zorobabel the son of Salathiel and Josue the son of Josedec rose up and resumed the construction of the house of God in Jerusalem, with the prophets standing beside them and assisting the work.
During that time, Thathanai, the imperial governor of the region beyond the river, arrived on the scene accompanied by Stharbuzanai and their administrative counselors. They questioned the builders directly, demanding to know who had authorized them to erect the structure and restore its surrounding walls. In response to this inquiry, the Jewish leaders provided the specific names of the men directing the building effort.
Because the watchful eye of God remained over the elders of the Jews, the Persian officials did not halt the construction. Instead, both parties agreed to submit the matter to King Darius, deferring any final resolution until the imperial court could review the accusation and receive their formal explanation.
Thathanai, Stharbuzanai, and their fellow counselors among the Arphasachites living beyond the river subsequently drafted an official dispatch to King Darius wishing him complete peace. In the letter, they reported that upon inspecting the province of Judea, they discovered the Jewish elders constructing the house of the great God using unpolished stones and laying timber into the walls. The governors noted that the project was proceeding with great diligence and advancing under the hands of the workers.
The letter explained that the Persian officials had interrogated the elders about who granted them authority to build the sanctuary and repair its walls, and had recorded the names of their leading men to inform the king. According to the report, the Jewish leaders identified themselves as servants of the God of heaven and earth. They explained that they were rebuilding a sacred edifice originally constructed many generations earlier by a renowned king of Israel. They acknowledged that when their ancestors provoked the God of heaven to anger, He handed them over to Nabuchodonosor the Chaldean king of Babylon, who demolished the sanctuary and exiled the population.
The elders further testified that in his first year as ruler of Babylon, King Cyrus issued a formal decree ordering this house of God to be reconstructed. Cyrus also removed from the Babylonian temple the sacred gold and silver vessels that Nabuchodonosor had plundered from Jerusalem, entrusting them to a governor named Sassabasar. Cyrus commanded Sassabasar to carry the sacred vessels back to Jerusalem and restore the house of God on its original site. Sassabasar then laid the temple's foundations, and the work had continued from that time down to the present without yet reaching completion.
Concluding their report, Thathanai and his associates requested that King Darius order a search of the royal archives in Babylon to determine whether King Cyrus had indeed issued a decree authorizing the rebuilding of the house of God in Jerusalem. They asked the monarch to communicate his royal decision and pleasure regarding the matter.
The story inside
Aggeus and Zacharias prophesied, and Zorobabel and Josue began building with their help. Thathanai and his associates asked who authorized the work and recorded the leaders’ names. The text says God’s eye was on the elders and the officials could not hinder them. Their letter to Darius reported the elders’ account of the temple’s destruction, Cyrus’s decree and the vessels entrusted to Sassabasar. It asked for a search in Babylon and the king’s decision; that decision is not given here.
Lessons worth keeping
- 1The prophets assisted Zorobabel and Josue when building resumed.
- 2The governors reported both their inspection and the elders’ stated authority to Darius.
- 3The letter requested verification of Cyrus’s decree; this chapter does not report a completed search.
Test your recall
Why did the governors ask Darius to search the royal library after hearing the elders’ account?
Source edition and notes
Douay–Rheims, revised by Richard Challoner (1749–1752). Project Gutenberg no. 1581. Locators refer to lines in the admitted pg1581.txt edition. Source notes may include Challoner commentary.
Lines 48310–48312
Then rose up Zorobabel the son of Salathiel, and Josue the son of Josedec, and began to build the temple of God in Jerusalem, and with them were the prophets of God helping them.
Lines 48322–48325
But the eye of their God was upon the ancients of the Jews, and they could not hinder them. And it was agreed that the matter should be referred to Darius, and then they should give satisfaction concerning that accusation.
Lines 48346–48349
We are the servants of the God of heaven and earth, and we are building a temple that was built these many years ago, and which a great king of Israel built and set up.
Lines 48373–48376
let him search in the king’s library, which is in Babylon, whether it hath been decreed by Cyrus the king, that the house of God in Jerusalem should be built
